Skip to content
Menu
CURRAJAH
  • Bookshop
  • HOME—WALLEAH PRESS
CURRAJAH
February 17, 2019February 16, 2022

Feedback for Michael Sharkey’s ‘Many Such As She: Victorian Australian Women Poets of World War One’

Some welcome feedback for Michael Sharkey’s anthology, Many Such as She….

“I’ve just been having another and deeper look into those women ‘war’ poets you’ve so
assiduously collected and wonderfully written up, and up till now I’ve found their
treatment of war, loss, patriotism, etc — by which I mean their favourite ‘positions’ to
couple up in thought with their absent men — quite troubling and, here and there,
alarming.That is, until I suddenly began to ‘hear’ it all quite differently — not as a
contemporary reader, but as a witness to their times. In fact, ‘times’ is the snuggly
fitting key, and you have to almost become a time-traveller to get back there. It’s not so
much a different world I find that they are living and thinking in — which would have to
be a nonsense, unless they were all mad — rather, they are using a language where
the words have different weights and values from our own. You have to make an effort
to free, or disencumber, their words from the interrogations that the language we at first
think they are using has subsequently been loaded with. Some of it, even making this
allowance, remains, however interesting as examples, affected, crude and even silly.
But a lot more becomes, in dramatic contrast, affecting and some seems to catch at
stunned moments of a genuine distress with flair and to be heart-breaking. Fine job
digger — or perhaps delver’s the truer word.”
¶¶
Michael’s response was to find the remarks pretty spot-on, regarding the way we read
the language of writers of another era. ‘It’s something that fascinated me all my reading
& teaching life —the way in which we get to enter another world’ — ‘time travelling’, as
he put it.— ‘so we can relive the thoughts & emotions of characters we encounter
there. We do that without resort to theory or any worry about ‘how’ we should read
such work from a bygone time. People who pick up a copy of some novel from the past
— say, Pride and Prejudice, or Gulliver’s Travels — don’t go into a fret about how to go
about it; they just open the book and engage with the language without any great
concern that some words may be a bit strange or that the punctuation’s not exactly
2019 style… they go at it in the same way that someone reads a newspaper online or
in print, or like people on a bus or plane or train read a contemporary detective story,
romance or biography. We’re not all conscious scholars of linguistics or historical
anthropology…. So the comments on the way we can read such people as those early
twentieth century women poets’ work are helpful. Their language does have certain
different values or weights embedded in it — words they took for granted as having
connotations as well as denotations according to the time they inhabited. We might put
a different weight on some words, but we still seem to effortlessly know what they were
getting at, and we unconsciously enter into their world view, even if we have different
attitudes to the meaning of a word like ‘duty’ or ‘peace’ or ‘love’ or ‘family’ nowadays.
We can understand the writers’ anxiety, fear and other passions. It’s why we can relate
to the love-poems of Lesbia Harford, or the cool outrage of Fullerton’s poem ‘The
Targets’, which another friend wrote to say that a reading aloud, by a woman who
teaches theatre, had a profound effect on an audience recently.’

Recent posts

  • Martyn Crucefix | Can AI Write an Original ‘Poem’ By ‘Me’?
  • Andrew Blackman – No, RSS isn’t dead!
  • Vanessa Proctor ~ ‘On Wonder’, a review
  • Henry Sheerwater – Vale
  • Louise Akers | 12 to 20 questions (from rob mclennan’s blog)

Categories

  • 3CR
  • A Chides Alphabet
  • ACT Literary Awards
  • Adamson, Bob
  • Adès, David
  • AI
  • Akers, louise
  • Albiston, Jordie
  • Allan, Alice
  • ALLMUSIC
  • Altman, Dennis
  • Amis, Martin
  • Anderson, Pat
  • Andrejeva, Kaciaryna
  • Anne Elder Award
  • Armantrout, Rae
  • Arnott, Robbie
  • Ashley, Melissa
  • Austin, Susan
  • Australia Institute
  • awards
  • Azimitabr, Mostafa ‘Moz’
  • Bailey, Thomas Forest
  • Baker, Tim
  • Bandesh, Farhad
  • Barnes, Melanie
  • Barton, Alison J.
  • Bell, Johanna
  • Bernstein, Charles
  • Berry, Colin
  • Bignell, Meg
  • Bircumshaw, David
  • Blackman, Andrew
  • Blackwood, Mary
  • Blakers, Rob
  • Bliss, Magenta
  • blog
  • Bolliger, Huni Melissa
  • book launch
  • book quotes
  • books
  • boult, jenny
  • Bowen, Kristy
  • Boyle, Peter
  • Brewster, Anne
  • Bright South
  • Brinklow, Laurie
  • Brophy, Kevin
  • Brown, Bob
  • Brozek, Daniela
  • Bruny Island Bird Festival
  • Burns, Anna
  • Byrne, Daragh
  • Byrne, Mairead
  • Cadden, Anna
  • Calanthe Press
  • Campbell, Marion May
  • Canetti, Elias
  • Carbis, Gayelene
  • Castlemaine Poetry Readings
  • children's books
  • City Park Radio
  • Clifton, Alison
  • climate change
  • Colette
  • Collins, Anne
  • Colville, Jan
  • Conan-Davies, Cally
  • conversations & interviews
  • Corbett, Nancy
  • Cordite Poetry Review
  • Corfiatis, Thérèse
  • Cossins, Jennifer
  • Couani, Anna
  • Cranston, CA
  • Crucefix, Martyn
  • Csik Zenekar
  • Daiza, Eliza Dune
  • DakhaBrakha
  • Davis, Megan
  • Didion, Joan
  • Dimitriadis, Koraly
  • Donlon, Ross
  • Drabble, Margaret
  • Drever, Chris
  • Dulcetly
  • Dumbly, Tug
  • Easton, Carol
  • Eberhard, Adrienne
  • Edmond, Martin
  • Edwards, Rachel
  • Einaudi, Ludovico
  • Ell, Theodore
  • Estrada, Silvana
  • Eureka Street
  • Evans, Alison
  • faith
  • festivals
  • fiction
  • Filreis, Al
  • FitzSimons, Peter
  • Five Islands Poetry Prize
  • Five Islands Press
  • Flanagan, Martin
  • Flanagan, Richard
  • Flett, Alison
  • Fowlis, Julie
  • Gallego, Ruben
  • Garcia-Navarro, Lulu
  • Giard-Chase, Ann
  • Gillespie, Alyssa
  • Gorton, John
  • Gotye
  • Greenhill, Susie
  • Grove, Simon
  • Haig, Francesca
  • haiku
  • Hay, Pete
  • Hecate
  • Herbert, Elanna
  • Hetherington, Graeme
  • Hey Rosetta!
  • Higgins, Kevin
  • Hindrum, Cameron
  • Hobart
  • Hobart Bookshop
  • Holland-Batt, Sarah
  • Hugo, Giles
  • Hunt, Julie
  • interviews
  • Ireland, David
  • Island
  • Jackson, Andy
  • Jackson, Eleanor
  • Jermy, Helga
  • Jones, Jill
  • Joris, Pierre
  • journals
  • Jurek, Thom
  • Kessler, Deirdre
  • Kidjo, Angélique
  • Kimbra
  • Kruimink, Kate
  • Laing, Harry
  • Launceston
  • Launceston Poetry Cup
  • Law, Archie
  • Law, Rebecca Kylie
  • Lawrence, Anthony
  • Layton-Bennett, Anne
  • Lea, Shelton
  • Leane, Jeanine
  • Lefroy, Liz
  • Lenker, Adrianne
  • Lilley, Kate
  • Liminal
  • Liquid Amber Press
  • Lomer, Kathryn
  • Lopo, Lisbet De Castro
  • MacKellar, Maggie
  • Mansell, Chris
  • Mantel, Hilary
  • Manus Island
  • March, Annie
  • Marr, David
  • Mason, David
  • McCusker, John
  • McGowan, Shane
  • mclennan, rob
  • McQuilkin, Liz
  • Melbourne Poetry Map
  • Meldrum, Petrina
  • Melrose, Shaine
  • memoir
  • Mercer, Gina
  • Middle East
  • Middleton, Kate
  • MILCK
  • Miles Franklin Award
  • Mok, Judith
  • Moss, Ron
  • New York Times
  • Nic Amhlaoibh, Muireann
  • Nielsen-Creeley, Kim
  • NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
  • O'Loughlin, Michael
  • Oakman, BJ
  • Otoliths
  • Ott, Teresa
  • Ottaway, Esther
  • Overland
  • Owen, David
  • Page, Vanessa
  • Paris Review
  • Patterson, Carol
  • Perera, Indrani
  • photography
  • Piko, Gregory
  • Poem Talk
  • poetry
  • poetry collections
  • Poetry London
  • Poetry Pedlars, Launceston
  • Poetry Says (podcast series)
  • poets
  • Poets on the Line
  • Poets' Express, The
  • Price, Jacinta
  • Proctor, Vanessa
  • Pybus, Cassandra
  • Rayner, Tony
  • Reaburn, Norman
  • Red Room Poetry
  • refugees
  • Reid, Harry
  • research
  • reviews
  • Riekki, Ron
  • Rochford Street Review
  • Rockman, Shoshanna
  • Rogers, Lars
  • Rothenberg, Jerome
  • Rowland, Robyn
  • Roy, Anuradha
  • RSS
  • Ryan, Brendan
  • Ryan, Tracy
  • Sakr, Omar
  • Saltbush Review
  • Schindler, Pam
  • science
  • Sculthorpe-Green, Nunami
  • Seasonal Poets
  • self-publishing
  • Sendra, Tim
  • Sharkey, Michael
  • Sheerwater, Henry
  • short stories
  • Simic, Charles
  • Skilbeck-Porter, Ella
  • Skovron, Alex
  • Slade, Tim
  • Small Press Network
  • Smith, Hazel
  • Sometimes, Alicia
  • song
  • Spaulding, Ralph
  • Spineless Wonders
  • Spoken Word, 3CR
  • Stenberg, Britta
  • Strummer, Joe
  • Swain, Helen
  • Tasmanian Literary Awards
  • Tasmanian Literary Awards 2022
  • Tasmanian Literary Awards 2025
  • Tasmanian Poetry Festival
  • The Richell Prize
  • thinking aloud
  • Thorne, Tim
  • Those Folk & The Inadequates
  • Tinmouth, Valerie
  • Tiny Desk Concert
  • Tokarczuk, Olga
  • Tredennick, Mark
  • Ukraine
  • Uluru Statement from the Heart
  • Uncategorized
  • US politics
  • Vale
  • Van Rijswijk, Philomena
  • Vaughan, Eleanor
  • Victorian Premier's Prize for Literature
  • Victorian Premier's Prize for Poetry
  • Webby, David
  • WestWords
  • Whish-Wilson, David
  • Whish-Wilson, Peter
  • White, Rachel
  • Whitebeach, Terry
  • Wicks, Les
  • wildness (online poetry journal)
  • Williams, Jane
  • Williams, Lucy
  • Winfield, Liz
  • Winton, Tim
  • Witek, Jules
  • Wood, Charlotte
  • Woodside
  • Woomble, Roddy
  • Woorilla Poetry Prize
  • Writers' Week, Adelaide Festival
  • Yee, Grace
  • Young, Damon
  • Young, Mark
  • Yukon Blonde
February 2019
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728  
« Dec   Aug »

Categories

  • 3CR
  • A Chides Alphabet
  • ACT Literary Awards
  • Adamson, Bob
  • Adès, David
  • AI
  • Akers, louise
  • Albiston, Jordie
  • Allan, Alice
  • ALLMUSIC
  • Altman, Dennis
  • Amis, Martin
  • Anderson, Pat
  • Andrejeva, Kaciaryna
  • Anne Elder Award
  • Armantrout, Rae
  • Arnott, Robbie
  • Ashley, Melissa
  • Austin, Susan
  • Australia Institute
  • awards
  • Azimitabr, Mostafa ‘Moz’
  • Bailey, Thomas Forest
  • Baker, Tim
  • Bandesh, Farhad
  • Barnes, Melanie
  • Barton, Alison J.
  • Bell, Johanna
  • Bernstein, Charles
  • Berry, Colin
  • Bignell, Meg
  • Bircumshaw, David
  • Blackman, Andrew
  • Blackwood, Mary
  • Blakers, Rob
  • Bliss, Magenta
  • blog
  • Bolliger, Huni Melissa
  • book launch
  • book quotes
  • books
  • boult, jenny
  • Bowen, Kristy
  • Boyle, Peter
  • Brewster, Anne
  • Bright South
  • Brinklow, Laurie
  • Brophy, Kevin
  • Brown, Bob
  • Brozek, Daniela
  • Bruny Island Bird Festival
  • Burns, Anna
  • Byrne, Daragh
  • Byrne, Mairead
  • Cadden, Anna
  • Calanthe Press
  • Campbell, Marion May
  • Canetti, Elias
  • Carbis, Gayelene
  • Castlemaine Poetry Readings
  • children's books
  • City Park Radio
  • Clifton, Alison
  • climate change
  • Colette
  • Collins, Anne
  • Colville, Jan
  • Conan-Davies, Cally
  • conversations & interviews
  • Corbett, Nancy
  • Cordite Poetry Review
  • Corfiatis, Thérèse
  • Cossins, Jennifer
  • Couani, Anna
  • Cranston, CA
  • Crucefix, Martyn
  • Csik Zenekar
  • Daiza, Eliza Dune
  • DakhaBrakha
  • Davis, Megan
  • Didion, Joan
  • Dimitriadis, Koraly
  • Donlon, Ross
  • Drabble, Margaret
  • Drever, Chris
  • Dulcetly
  • Dumbly, Tug
  • Easton, Carol
  • Eberhard, Adrienne
  • Edmond, Martin
  • Edwards, Rachel
  • Einaudi, Ludovico
  • Ell, Theodore
  • Estrada, Silvana
  • Eureka Street
  • Evans, Alison
  • faith
  • festivals
  • fiction
  • Filreis, Al
  • FitzSimons, Peter
  • Five Islands Poetry Prize
  • Five Islands Press
  • Flanagan, Martin
  • Flanagan, Richard
  • Flett, Alison
  • Fowlis, Julie
  • Gallego, Ruben
  • Garcia-Navarro, Lulu
  • Giard-Chase, Ann
  • Gillespie, Alyssa
  • Gorton, John
  • Gotye
  • Greenhill, Susie
  • Grove, Simon
  • Haig, Francesca
  • haiku
  • Hay, Pete
  • Hecate
  • Herbert, Elanna
  • Hetherington, Graeme
  • Hey Rosetta!
  • Higgins, Kevin
  • Hindrum, Cameron
  • Hobart
  • Hobart Bookshop
  • Holland-Batt, Sarah
  • Hugo, Giles
  • Hunt, Julie
  • interviews
  • Ireland, David
  • Island
  • Jackson, Andy
  • Jackson, Eleanor
  • Jermy, Helga
  • Jones, Jill
  • Joris, Pierre
  • journals
  • Jurek, Thom
  • Kessler, Deirdre
  • Kidjo, Angélique
  • Kimbra
  • Kruimink, Kate
  • Laing, Harry
  • Launceston
  • Launceston Poetry Cup
  • Law, Archie
  • Law, Rebecca Kylie
  • Lawrence, Anthony
  • Layton-Bennett, Anne
  • Lea, Shelton
  • Leane, Jeanine
  • Lefroy, Liz
  • Lenker, Adrianne
  • Lilley, Kate
  • Liminal
  • Liquid Amber Press
  • Lomer, Kathryn
  • Lopo, Lisbet De Castro
  • MacKellar, Maggie
  • Mansell, Chris
  • Mantel, Hilary
  • Manus Island
  • March, Annie
  • Marr, David
  • Mason, David
  • McCusker, John
  • McGowan, Shane
  • mclennan, rob
  • McQuilkin, Liz
  • Melbourne Poetry Map
  • Meldrum, Petrina
  • Melrose, Shaine
  • memoir
  • Mercer, Gina
  • Middle East
  • Middleton, Kate
  • MILCK
  • Miles Franklin Award
  • Mok, Judith
  • Moss, Ron
  • New York Times
  • Nic Amhlaoibh, Muireann
  • Nielsen-Creeley, Kim
  • NPR Music Tiny Desk Concert
  • O'Loughlin, Michael
  • Oakman, BJ
  • Otoliths
  • Ott, Teresa
  • Ottaway, Esther
  • Overland
  • Owen, David
  • Page, Vanessa
  • Paris Review
  • Patterson, Carol
  • Perera, Indrani
  • photography
  • Piko, Gregory
  • Poem Talk
  • poetry
  • poetry collections
  • Poetry London
  • Poetry Pedlars, Launceston
  • Poetry Says (podcast series)
  • poets
  • Poets on the Line
  • Poets' Express, The
  • Price, Jacinta
  • Proctor, Vanessa
  • Pybus, Cassandra
  • Rayner, Tony
  • Reaburn, Norman
  • Red Room Poetry
  • refugees
  • Reid, Harry
  • research
  • reviews
  • Riekki, Ron
  • Rochford Street Review
  • Rockman, Shoshanna
  • Rogers, Lars
  • Rothenberg, Jerome
  • Rowland, Robyn
  • Roy, Anuradha
  • RSS
  • Ryan, Brendan
  • Ryan, Tracy
  • Sakr, Omar
  • Saltbush Review
  • Schindler, Pam
  • science
  • Sculthorpe-Green, Nunami
  • Seasonal Poets
  • self-publishing
  • Sendra, Tim
  • Sharkey, Michael
  • Sheerwater, Henry
  • short stories
  • Simic, Charles
  • Skilbeck-Porter, Ella
  • Skovron, Alex
  • Slade, Tim
  • Small Press Network
  • Smith, Hazel
  • Sometimes, Alicia
  • song
  • Spaulding, Ralph
  • Spineless Wonders
  • Spoken Word, 3CR
  • Stenberg, Britta
  • Strummer, Joe
  • Swain, Helen
  • Tasmanian Literary Awards
  • Tasmanian Literary Awards 2022
  • Tasmanian Literary Awards 2025
  • Tasmanian Poetry Festival
  • The Richell Prize
  • thinking aloud
  • Thorne, Tim
  • Those Folk & The Inadequates
  • Tinmouth, Valerie
  • Tiny Desk Concert
  • Tokarczuk, Olga
  • Tredennick, Mark
  • Ukraine
  • Uluru Statement from the Heart
  • Uncategorized
  • US politics
  • Vale
  • Van Rijswijk, Philomena
  • Vaughan, Eleanor
  • Victorian Premier's Prize for Literature
  • Victorian Premier's Prize for Poetry
  • Webby, David
  • WestWords
  • Whish-Wilson, David
  • Whish-Wilson, Peter
  • White, Rachel
  • Whitebeach, Terry
  • Wicks, Les
  • wildness (online poetry journal)
  • Williams, Jane
  • Williams, Lucy
  • Winfield, Liz
  • Winton, Tim
  • Witek, Jules
  • Wood, Charlotte
  • Woodside
  • Woomble, Roddy
  • Woorilla Poetry Prize
  • Writers' Week, Adelaide Festival
  • Yee, Grace
  • Young, Damon
  • Young, Mark
  • Yukon Blonde
©2025 CURRAJAH | Powered by WordPress and Superb Themes!